Course MT3818 Topics in Geometry

Solutions 6

  1. The direct symmetries or rotations of the tetrahedron map to the elements of A4 × {I} ⊆ S4 × < J >.
    The opposite symmetries of the tetrahedron map to symmetries of the cube of the form P × J where P is an odd permutation in S4.
    The kernel of the map is trivial.

  2. All the opposite symmetries of the dodecahedron are rotatory inversions. That is, they are of the form JR with R a rotation.
    Hence by Exercises 4 question 4 they are all rotatory reflections. The only ones which are actually reflections are those of the form JH with H a half turn and the only half-turns which are rotatory symmetries of the dodecahedron have axes joining the centres of pairs of opposite edges.
    There are 15 such pairs and the reflections are then in the planes through the mid-points perpendicular to these pairs of edges.

  3. The groups C2 , C1 × < J > , C2 C1 are all cyclic groups of order 2.
    However, C2 is generated by a half turn H, C1 × < J > is generated by central inversion J , while C2 C1 is the mixed group generated by JH which is reflection in a plane.
    Hence these three are not conjugate in I(R3).

  4. To get a figure with rotation group Cn and no opposite symmetries paint a symbol like (but with n "arms") with only rotational symmetry on the bottom face of a pyramid on a regular n-gon.
    Painting the same figure on the top and bottom faces of an n-prism will give a figure with rotation group Dn and no opposite symmetries.
    Paint a (suitable situated) 3-armed version of this figure on each face of a tetrahedron, octahedron or icosahedron to get figures with the requisite rotation groups but no opposite symmetries.

    For figures with full symmetry group Dn × < J > take either a prism (n even) or an anti-prism (n odd).
    Paint the above symbol on the top and J(this symbol) on the bottom to get a figure with full symmetry group Cn × < J >.
    The stella-octangula, cube and dodecahedron give examples of centrally symmetric figures with direct symmetry groups of the Platonic figures.

  5. The mixed group Dn Cn consists of n rotations (by multiples of 2π/n about the same axis) and n opposite symmetries of the form JH with H a half turn, which are reflections in planes containing this axis.
    Suitable figures include a right pyramid on a regular n-gonal base or an n-prism with its top surface painted a different colour.

    Choose a figure with full symmetry group Dn × < J > . (Either a prism or anti-prism depending on the parity of n.) Then mark a symbol like with only rotational symmetry on the top face and J(this symbol) on the bottom face.
    This figure will then have Cn × < J > as its full symmetry group.

    Similarly, when the full symmetry group of the prism/anti-prism is the mixed group D2n Dn marking such symbols on the upper and lower n-gons will give a figure whose full symmetry group is C2n Cn.

    1. Position a corner to see that for the direct symmetry group we have |Sd| = 4.
      The direct symmetries are the same as the direct symmetries of the rectangle where the tiles meet and so Sd = D2 .
      Since the figure has central symmetry, the full symmetry group is Sd × < J > = D2 × < J >.
    2. Again |Sd| = 4 and Sd = D2 (the identity and rotation by π about three mutually perpendicular axes). This time the figure is not centrally symmetric but it does have some opposite symmetries. So the full symmetry group is a mixed group and the only possibility is D4D2 .
    3. As before Sd = D2 but this time there are no opposite symmetries and so the full symmetry group is also D2 .

    Colouring the tiles removes some of the possible symmetries. We get :
    1. Sd = C2 and S = D2C2 since there is now no central symmetry.
    2. Sd = C2 and S = D2C2
    3. Sd = C2 and S = C2

  6. A half-turn about an axis joining the centres of opposite edges gives a transposition of the diagonals. So these 6 elements correspond to odd permutations. The other odd permutations (all 4-cycles) correspond to 6 rotation about centres of faces by ±π/2. All the other symmetries correspond to even permutations.

    Mapping the group of the cube to S6 rotations by ±π/2 about face centres map to 4-cycles. Rotations by 2π/3 about diagonals map to cycles of the shape ( . . . )( . . . ). Half turns about diagonals or axes joining edge centres map to cycles of the shape ( . . )( . . )( . . )